Review: Old Elk Continues to Master Wheated Whiskey

“Extreme” wheat mashbills get a revision with two new limited releases from this Colorado distillery

May 11, 2022 6:00 am
A close-up of an Old Elk Double Wheat bottle
How much more wheated can you get, asks Old Elk.
Old Elk

What we’re drinking: Old Elk Double Wheat Straight Whiskey and Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey, part of the distillery’s Master’s Blend Series

Where it’s from: Based in Fort Collins, Colorado, Old Elk is headed up by Master Distiller Greg Metze, a 40-plus-year vet of the whiskey world who spent 14 of those years as the Master Distiller for MGP/LDI. 

Why we’re drinking this: In its relatively short lifespan — the brand launched in 2013 — Old Elk has mastered the “wheated” whiskey category. So we were curious what these new limited releases could do with their wheat-forward mashbills.  

“The wheated whisky and wheated bourbon came out a little over a year ago, and the mashbills on those two are extreme relative to the categories,” says Metze. “And I realized we could create mashbills within mashbills with those and create something really different.” Here, that means two wheat-centric releases that aren’t quite as extreme as Old Elk’s core wheated lineup, but also unusual for being a bourbon and a four-grain whiskey.

Interestingly, Metze doesn’t go into these special projects knowing what the final product will produce. “The percentages on the mashbills that I think will be a home run never come to fruition,” admits Metze. “So instead, I look for one that stands out and has different aspects I think are pleasing. But I don’t really blend to specific descriptors.” 

Old Elk Four Grain and Double Wheat
Old Elk Four Grain and Double Wheat, now available in limited quantities
Old Elk

How it tastes:

  • Old Elk Double Wheat Straight Whiskey: A combination of Old Elk Straight Wheat Whiskey (aged 6-8 years) and Old Elk Wheated Bourbon (aged 6 years), this 107.1 proof release features a blend breakdown of 71.5% wheat, 25% corn and 3.5% barley. Candied fruit and butterscotch on the nose, this one delivers pepper, burnt caramel and some bready and jammy notes on the palate, complete with a rich mouthfeel and some lingering fruit.
  • Old Elk Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey is a blend of four cereal grains (51% corn, 22.5% wheat, 19% barley, 7.5% rye), aged 6-7 years with an ABV of 52.95%. The rye is surprisingly powerful here, but tempered by a caramel corn sweetness, almond and heavy vanilla notes. For a bourbon, this one could work for rye or wheater fans.

Fun fact: Metze (along with Beverage Director Melinda Maddox) also oversees Whiskeysmith, a flavored whiskey we actually recommend.

Where to buy: These Old Elk Master Blend Series expressions are part of a national limited release, available at select retailers with a suggested retail price of $99.99 per 750 ml bottle. You’ll also be able to order it online soon.

MEET US AT YOUR INBOX. FIRST ROUND'S ON US.

Join America's Fastest Growing Spirits Newsletter THE SPILL. Unlock all the reviews, recipes and revelry — and get 15% off award-winning La Tierra de Acre Mezcal.